Virginia HOA law
Is your Virginia HOA a real property owners' association?
Some older Virginia subdivisions have an association that bills owners but was never set up the way the law requires. A February 2026 appeals decision shows what happens then, and what to look for in the recorded declaration before you buy.
Working through a disclosure packet right now?
HOA Notes reads the whole package against Virginia law and sends back a risk score, the red flags ranked by severity, and a page citation behind every finding. Usually within the hour.
What makes an HOA legal under the Virginia Property Owners' Association Act
The Property Owners' Association Act (Title 55.1, Chapter 18) covers lot developments, not condominiums. Section 55.1-1800 defines a property owners' association as an entity "upon which responsibilities are imposed and to which authority is granted in the declaration." The declaration is the instrument recorded in the county or city land records. Bylaws, a website, or the association's own habits don't count.
The Supreme Court of Virginia has read that definition to require two things together: the power to collect a fixed assessment or to make variable assessments, and a corresponding duty to maintain the common area. Both must be expressly stated in a recorded instrument, and neither can be implied. The court set this out in Anderson v. Lake Arrowhead Civic Association (1997) and repeated it in the two Dogwood Valley Citizens Association cases (2004 and 2008). In the second Dogwood case, it added that taking on maintenance voluntarily is not enough. The duty has to be imposed.
What happened in Terrace View v. Jannah (2026)
Terrace View is a subdivision in Forest, Virginia, and the case came up from the Bedford County Circuit Court. Its recorded declaration, from 2000, allowed for an optional association and said it "shall have the right to establish and collect assessments." The association was incorporated in 2005, sat inactive until 2014, and in 2022 billed the Jannahs, who own lots there, an association fee. They refused to pay and sued for a declaratory judgment.
The Court of Appeals affirmed summary judgment for the owners. The declaration gave the association a right to assess but imposed no duty to maintain the common area. The bylaws did contain a maintenance duty, but the court said a duty that can be removed by amending the bylaws is not imposed. So Terrace View was not a property owners' association under the Act.
The court then asked whether the declaration was still an enforceable contract. A covenant can support an assessment even without the Act. In Anderson, a recorded covenant set $20 a year for the first lot and $10 for each additional lot, for general maintenance, and that was enforceable. Terrace View's clause named no amount, no way to set one, and no purpose for the money, so the court held it too indefinite to enforce. The owners had paid assessments in the past, and one had served on the board. The court said neither fact affected the result.
Does the 2024 change to section 55.1-1805 let any Virginia HOA charge assessments?
No. In 2024 the General Assembly added a sentence to section 55.1-1805 (Acts 2024, chapter 685): nothing in the chapter prevents "an association from levying or using assessments, charges, or fees to pay the association's contractual or other legal obligations." Terrace View argued that this relaxed the two-part test. The Court of Appeals disagreed. The sentence assumes a validly formed association already exists. It answered a 2023 case, Burkholder v. Palisades Park Owners Association, about what a valid association can spend assessments on. It did not change the definitions in section 55.1-1800.
What the ruling does not settle
The case does not reach condominiums or cooperatives. The Act's definition of a declaration excludes them, and they have their own statutes. The association also raised a different argument on appeal: that a declaration tying assessments to "maintenance or services" for the lots is enough. The court did not decide it, because the argument had not been made in the trial court. And the case was about this association's power to assess. The opinion does not say whether lot owners can enforce the covenants against each other.
Finality is also open. Secondary reports say the association asked the Supreme Court of Virginia to review the decision. As of November 19, 2026, we could not confirm whether that court granted or refused the petition. The two-part test itself comes from the Supreme Court's own earlier cases, so it is not new law. How it applies to a particular declaration can still change if the higher court takes the case.
What a buyer should look for in the recorded declaration
Get the recorded declaration and every recorded amendment or supplement from the circuit court clerk's land records, or from the resale certificate. Then check:
- A sentence that puts a duty on the association to maintain, repair, or operate the common area, roads, or amenities. It should say the association shall do this, not that it may.
- A sentence that gives the association power to levy assessments, either a fixed amount or a method for setting variable assessments.
- Whether the maintenance duty appears only in the bylaws or articles of incorporation. Under Terrace View, a duty found only there does not count.
- Whether the assessment clause names an amount or formula and a purpose for the money. A bare right to establish and collect assessments was too vague in Terrace View.
- Recorded amendments. The Act's definition of a declaration includes amendments and supplements, so a later recorded document may add what the original lacked.
- Whether the association registered with the Common Interest Community Board. Registration is required, but it does not make an association valid. Terrace View registered in 2014 and still lost.
Why this matters to your offer
A valid Virginia property owners' association can file a lien and, past $5,000 in secured sums, foreclose for unpaid assessments. A body that does not qualify has none of the Act's powers. Its dues may be voluntary or limited to what a definite covenant spells out. Before you budget around the dues, or decide whether they are optional, find out which kind of association you are buying into. Do not stop paying an existing association on the strength of this page. Have a Virginia real estate attorney read the recorded documents first.
An HOA Notes brief reads the declaration in your packet and flags whether it imposes a maintenance duty and grants assessment power. It cites the page for each finding, so you can take the question to your agent or attorney before your cancellation window closes.
What the statute says
Virginia Code section 55.1-1800 (What makes a valid POA). Section 55.1-1800 defines a property owners' association as an entity on which responsibilities are imposed and to which authority is granted in the declaration, a recorded instrument. Virginia courts read this to require both the power to levy assessments and a corresponding duty to maintain the common area, expressly stated in a recorded instrument; a duty found only in the bylaws or taken on voluntarily does not count (Anderson, 1997; Dogwood Valley, 2004 and 2008; Terrace View POA v. Jannah, Ct. App. Va., published, Feb. 3, 2026). An entity that does not qualify is not a POA under the Act. An entity that is not a POA may still collect an assessment that a recorded covenant states with a definite amount (or a standard for it) and purpose (Anderson); in Terrace View a bare right to establish and collect assessments was too indefinite. The 2024 amendment to 55.1-1805 lets a valid association use assessments for its contractual or other legal obligations but, per Terrace View, does not relax the test. The definition excludes condominium and cooperative declarations.
When you read the disclosure packet, watch for declaration grants a right to collect assessments but imposes no duty to maintain any common area, the only maintenance duty appears in the bylaws, not the recorded declaration, assessment clause states no amount, formula, or purpose for the money, and voluntary civic association billing lot owners as if dues were mandatory. HOA Notes flags each of these against the statute and tells you which restrictions are actually enforceable.
Get your HOA packet read against Virginia law.
Upload the full disclosure package and HOA Notes runs the state-calibrated analysis. Risk Score, red-flag list, 5 verbatim agent talking points, page citations on every claim, and a coverage gaps list showing what to request from the HOA. Delivered in under an hour.
$59
per packet - one-time, no subscription
Order a brief for your packetVirginia property owners' associations: common questions
Can a voluntary HOA in Virginia make me pay dues?
Usually not as an association under the Property Owners' Association Act. Virginia courts require the recorded declaration to give the association both assessment power and a duty to maintain the common area, and a duty taken on voluntarily does not count. A group that does not qualify can collect only what a recorded covenant spells out with a definite amount and purpose, as in Anderson v. Lake Arrowhead (1997).
What makes an HOA legal under the Virginia Property Owners' Association Act?
Its recorded declaration must expressly give it the power to collect a fixed assessment or make variable assessments, and must impose a corresponding duty to maintain the common area. That test comes from the Supreme Court of Virginia's reading of Code section 55.1-1800 in Anderson (1997) and the Dogwood Valley cases (2004 and 2008). The Court of Appeals applied it in Terrace View v. Jannah in February 2026.
Can my Virginia HOA collect fees if the declaration doesn't require it to maintain common areas?
Not as a property owners' association. In Terrace View v. Jannah (Ct. App. Va., February 3, 2026), the declaration let the association collect assessments but imposed no maintenance duty, so the court held it was not a property owners' association. The court also held its open-ended assessment clause too indefinite to enforce as a contract. A covenant that names an amount and a purpose may still be enforceable.
Does the 2024 change to 55.1-1805 let any Virginia HOA charge assessments?
No. The 2024 sentence (Acts 2024, chapter 685) says the chapter does not prevent an association from using assessments to pay its contractual or other legal obligations. In Terrace View, the Court of Appeals held that it assumes a validly formed association already exists. It did not change the definitions in section 55.1-1800 or relax the rule that the declaration must impose a maintenance duty.
Does a maintenance duty in the bylaws count?
No. In Terrace View the bylaws told the board to maintain the common property, but the Court of Appeals said that duty was not imposed, because the association could remove it by amending its own bylaws. Following Dogwood Valley (2008), the duty has to be in a recorded instrument such as the declaration or a recorded amendment to it.
Does Terrace View apply to Virginia condominiums?
No. The Property Owners' Association Act's definition of a declaration in Code section 55.1-1800 excludes condominium and cooperative declarations. Condominiums are governed by the Virginia Condominium Act, so the two-part test in Terrace View is about lot developments, such as single-family subdivisions and townhouse communities that are not condominiums.
Is the Terrace View decision final?
We could not confirm that. Secondary reports say the association asked the Supreme Court of Virginia to review it, and as of November 19, 2026 we found no order granting or refusing the petition. The opinion is published, and its two-part test repeats the Supreme Court's own earlier holdings, but how the test applies could change if the higher court takes the case.
Sources, verified 2026-11-19
The statements about Virginia law on this page were checked on 2026-11-19 against the published Court of Appeals opinion and the Code of Virginia on law.lis.virginia.gov, with an independent law-firm summary of the same decision as a second source. Section 55.1-1800 holds the definitions; the two-part test comes from Supreme Court of Virginia cases that read those definitions. Case law and statutes change; confirm the current status before relying on it.
Researched and reviewed by the HOA Notes Editorial Team, which verifies every legal claim on this page against the primary statutory source below.
- Terrace View Property Owner's Ass'n v. Jannah, Record No. 2007-24-3 (Ct. App. Va. Feb. 3, 2026) (published), Court of Appeals of Virginia. Verified 2026-11-19. vacourts.gov
- Code of Virginia section 55.1-1800 (definitions), Virginia General Assembly. Verified 2026-11-19. law.lis.virginia.gov
- Code of Virginia section 55.1-1805 (association charges), Virginia General Assembly. Verified 2026-11-19. law.lis.virginia.gov
- Surprise HOA assessments may not be legally enforceable (Feb. 7, 2026), BerlikLaw (Virginia Business Litigation Lawyer blog). Verified 2026-11-19. virginiabusinesslitigationlawyer.com
About this page
Last reviewed 2026-11-19. This page is a general buyer guide and a description of the HOA Notes service. HOA Notes is not a law firm and this is not legal advice. Whether a particular Virginia association qualifies under the Property Owners' Association Act depends on the exact wording of its recorded documents, and Terrace View may still be reviewed by the Supreme Court of Virginia. Consult a Virginia real estate attorney before withholding any payment or relying on anything described here.